Sinister: #3 and label stuff
mayfly the fly
bluevelour at xxx.com
Tue Jan 13 19:58:15 GMT 1998
The online magazine allstar (http://www.allstarmag.com) named IYFS
as it's #3 album of the year behind Radiohead and Spiritualized, which
is pretty good company. The review follows, it's very flattering, almost
rapturous.
This band is so splendid, their mixture of erudite string/
horn arrangements, sensitively sung vocals, rolling grooves,
rockist rhythm guitars, and carousel organs is delicious.
These Scottish folks' cross- pollinated, lush sound savvily
recalls the creme de la creme of erudite pop history -- so
many things at once you don't know where to begin.
It's hard to resist playing the back of the bus fanboy
game of What if: What if in the '60s the Kinks had
collaborated with Lou Reed, produced by Burt Bacharach? Or
in the '70s, if Nick Drake had cut a few sides with Roxy
Music, with Jack Nitzsche producing? Or in the '80s, if Felt
had recorded with the June Brides and Feelies, John Cale in
the control booth? Belle and Sebastian sound like all of
these things, sort of. Do people really think they sound
like the Smiths? That group is so histrionic and self-
important. B&S (not the names of anyone in the band) are too
smart to care whether meat is murder or not. They want to
know how it's cooked.
There's lots of bands that sound good, especially in
1997. You've got Movietone, Stereolab, Yo La Tengo, Richard
Davies, Home, Mogwai, the High Llamas, Fuck, Smog,
Broadcast, the Elephant 6 collective, the Lilys -- everyone
sounds good, the pop life is a party where everyhting goes
right... except maybe in the words department. The
conversation, the lyrics are a bit lacking in general.
But Belle and Sebastian's words are the tops, the
dandy-ish extreme. They're like Oscar Wilde showing up for
supper. There's not only a bite to their humor that recalls
Mark E. Smith, a pathos that reminds one of Eitzel, and a
dainty way with words that hints at Nick Drake, but an
ironic edge that's as sharp as the Monochrome Set, and as
full of life as the Kinks: "Could I write a requiem for you
when you're dead?/ 'She had the moves, she had the speed, it
went to her head'/ She never needed anything to get her
round the track/ But when she's on her back/ She had the
knowledge/ To get her into college" -- from "The Stars of
Track and Field." Bravo, bravo. I'm holding my breath until
the Matador record is released.
-Mike McGonigal
______________________________________________________
Get Your Private, Free Email at http://www.hotmail.com
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
. This message was brought to you by the Sinister mailing list.
. To send to the list please mail "sinister at majordomo.net".
. For subscribing, unsubscribing and other list information please see
. http://www.majordomo.net/sinister
. For questions about how the list works mail owner-sinister at majordomo.net
. We're all happy bunnies humming happy bunny tunes. Aren't we?
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
More information about the Sinister
mailing list